SOUTH TYROL: ITALIANIZATION THROUGH INDUSTRIALIZATION
Germans have not always been on the ‘giving end’ of European imperialism and colonization. Finding themselves on the ‘receiving end’, they also faced language bans and cultural erasures, a state-orchestrated influx of settlers from other parts of the invading country, extraction of cheap resources (in this case, hydropower) for the sake of the state-sponsored military industrial complex, expropriation of ancestral lands, and other colonial policies. It was all called ‘Italianization’ and followed Italy’s formal annexation of South Tyrol that the Italian army had captured at the end of WWI, as was secretly agreed in the 1915 Treaty of London*. The German-speaking Tyroleans fought back with underground resistance, clandestine schools, and terrorism. The South Tyrolean question has officially been only solved in 1992 but controversy, trauma, and mistrust between the region’s two communities — German and Italian — live on in this seemingly placid and beautiful place. But let’s start from the beginning.
While some of the European empires had collapsed as a result of WWI, Italy had only then started to create one of its own, a process that seems to have culminated in a 1936 speech by Mussolini: ‘Italy finally has its empire’. In the Italian case, its colonial expansions were closely intertwined with the fascist ideology. Tyrol, once a single Austrian crown land** that the Habsburg dynasty ruled from the 14th century, consisted of three major regions of which only the southernmost, Trento, had an Italian-speaking majority. Italy, however, did not settle with just Trento and annexed one German-speaking part of Tyrol as well. Today it is known as South Tyrol, or Alto Adige in Italian.
By the time of Mussolini’s infamous speech, locals had already fully felt the way the nascent fascist empire saw its minorities and their territories. Italy’s claims on Tyrol were of linguistic (part of it was Italian-speaking), geographic (an important water divide), military (a deep enemy salient into the Italian territory), and economic (cheap hydropower) nature but, as all other empires, it had to deal with a hostile indigenous population with centuries-old local roots. By 1919, ca. 96% of South Tyrol’s population were German speakers identifying themselves with either Austria or Germany. The Italian government soon began its far-fetched Italianization program nonetheless.
A general view of the Bolzano Industrial Area. Built in the 1930s on the confiscated land and expanded after WWII, it served as a major vehicle of the forced Italianization of South Tyrol. December 2023
While it based its colonial policies both on the classic trope of a civilizing mission and a racialized suppression of allogeni, or ‘aliens’ (labeling them with copy-book accusations of backwardness and untrustworthiness), it faced a peculiar ideological controversy in South Tyrol. Here, even Mussolini-appointed advisers recognized it was Italy that was supposed to learn from the more efficient local farming practices and legal system rather than the other way around. One of the first discursive concepts put forward to handle this problem was to portray the German-speaking Tyroleans as Germanized Italians who just needed to rediscover their Italianness. This, however, was enforced with cruel measures that encompassed both public and private spheres and included a complete ban on the German language in the administration, politics, courts, schools public and private, and even in kindergartens. Almost all of the German newspapers were closed, monuments torn down, local apparatus purged of Austrians to replace them with Italians appointed from Rome. Most of the German towns, villages, streets, castles, rivers, and even mountains were renamed while the residents were forced to adopt Italian personal names. Severe prosecution awaited those who attempted to resist, such as Catholic priests who swiftly organized the so-called German catacomb schools.
A decade into the program, the fascist government realized it just did not work as intended and decided to complement it with mass immigration from elsewhere in Italy to try and change demographics.
A view from the former aluminum factory I.N.A. Montecatini (one of its Art Deco green-roofed front offices is visible in the foreground) now redeveloped into a business park, to one of the facilities of the still fully operational military vehicle factory IDV (Iveco Defense Vehicles), formerly Lancia. Both were built in the mid-to-late-1930s in the newly created Bolzano Industrial Area. December 2023
This, however, was only one of the two primary goals, the other being the rapid industrialization of this largely agricultural province to develop the domestic military industrial complex. By the late 1930s, a large industrial area with steel, chemicals, machine-building and other factories was planned and built in Bolzano (Bozen) — today’s regional capital — mostly on confiscated agricultural land to the south of the old Austrian town. New railways and cheap hydropower from local mountain rivers harnessed through construction of numerous power plants largely contributed to the rapid development of these newly created industries. To house the incoming workforce, housing estates (case operaie) were built from scratch in the Italian rationalist style, with new streets named after Italian major cities, new colonies, such as Rhodes, or territorial claims, such as Dalmatia, to solidify the city’s new Italian identity.
Via Rodi, or Rhodes Street, runs between Via Torino and Via Dalmazia in Europa-Novacella (Europa-Neustift) — the oldest core of the working class neighborhood in Bolzano constructed in the mid-to-late-1930s for workers resettled here en masse from other regions of Italy to work in the newly created Bolzano Industrial Area. The neighborhood’s original name, Rione Littoria, was a clear reference to one of the main symbols of fascism — the fasces (fascio littorio in Italian). Two street names here are also telling: Rhodes and the whole Greek-populated Dodecanese Archipelago in the Aegean Sea, captured from the Ottoman Empire, were an Italian colony from 1912 to 1943. Dalmatia, another former Austro-Hungarian crown land with a Croat majority and an Italian minority, was promised to Italy by the same Treaty of London as Tyrol but ended up part of the newly formed Yugoslavia. Italy occupied Dalmatia from 1941-43, so Via Dalmazia was effectively named after a territorial claim. December 2023
In this way, industrialization in South Tyrol became synonymous with mass immigration and land colonization. Though it did not succeed in fully marginalizing or assimilating the German-speaking majority of South Tyrol in general, it drastically changed the cityscape and economy of the city of Bolzano, turning this once sleepy provincial Austrian town into a large industrial center and substantially increasing the region’s Italian-speaking community. Today, Bolzano is South Tyrol’s only municipality where Italian speakers constitute a majority of ca. 74% vs. only 10% in the pre-WWI time.
Though some of the traumatizing language rules remain unchanged to this day, the post-WWII economic miracle and lengthy international negotiations allowed to finally settle the South Tyrolean question by giving the region broad powers of autonomy, both political and cultural, and making it one of the country’s wealthiest and most developed provinces. The road to this wasn’t an easy one though, with the anti-Italian resistance after WWII morphing into an underground terrorist organization, BAS (Befreiungsausschuss Südtirol, or South Tyrolean Liberation Committee). It operated from the mid-1950s to late 1980s, committing more than 360 attacks during this time, including those with civilian casualties and the infamous 1961 Night of Fire when they blew up tens of power pylons, cutting off electricity supply to the Bolzano Industrial Area that they viewed as a symbol of forced Italianization.
* In order to lure Italy into WWI on their side against the Central Powers, the UK, France, and Russia promised Italy future enlargements into territories and colonies in Europe and Africa then held by Austria-Hungary and Turkey.
** Crown lands (Kronländer) were constituent entities of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.